Articles with tag: trash

11/03/2026 _Perspective

Mourning Trash and Haunting Bodies

A Comparative Dialogue Between Modern Finnish Waste Discourse and Classical Japanese Courtly Tales

_Dialogue A philosopher, P, and a Japanologist, J, walk together down the riverbank of the Aura, in Turku, Finland. It’s an early spring afternoon, cold but clear. Old snow and pebbles punctuate the cobblestones by the still naked trees. P: Finland is so clean; there’s hardly any trash on the streets. And we have the cleanest air in the world, did you know? [1] We have all the health benefits of clean air and clean cities, like better sleep and a better mood. The place in the world with the cleanest air is actually in Finland, in Pallas-Yllästunturi National Park. [2] Here, we pay a lot of attention to cleanliness. Clean air, water, and food. You can even pick berries and mushrooms in the forests and eat them; [3] that’s how clean Finland is. J: It really sounds almost utopian when you look at all the information from national and local websites! And yet, it is interesting to consider when we think of something as dirt. Look at this gravel scattered all through the streets. In winter it makes paths safer and cleaner. But in spring, when the snow melts, it becomes dirt and dust. P: A lot of Finnish street cleaning discourse is devoted to when and how the stones should be cleaned in the spring. [4] You could say this is an example of dirt as “matter out of place.” [5] This is a concept popularized by Mary Douglas in the 1960s, but she didn’t originate it. It was a pre-existing Victorian phrase, employed in a speech by British Prime Minister Lord Palmerston (1784–1865), talking about urban planning ideals. [6] At this time, England was dealing with an ‘urban blight’ where rapid industrialization and inequality caused destitute urban dwellers to live in close quarters in unsanitary living conditions. Waste management was insufficient for such large groups of people in such small areas, and Lord Palmerston’s position was that natural byproducts were essentially good. The problem was not waste itself (as human and food waste make perfectly good fertilizer if managed properly), but waste management. [7] J: From how you are talking, I thought you were going to tell me the bodies living in close quarters were the matter out of place and not the waste they produced! Because both waste and bodies are like this gravel we were talking about. They could fulfil particular social functions when organized…

10/31/2024 _Perspective

Producing Trash

The Labor of Difficult Theory in the University

1_Introduction In the university, teachers and students alike constantly produce trash: knowledge, represented in formal and informal verbal and written statements, that fails to meet the institutional standards of quality. Such knowledge isn’t inherently trashy; rather, it is turned into trash. Epistemic content undergoes a process of evaluation against formal (structure, clarity, length, language, and so forth) and substantive criteria (argument, originality, contribution, etc.); once evaluated—for instance, in a seminar discussion, or in the grading of a paper—and its areas of failure established, a verdict is issued. Whether in the eye roll of a colleague, a teacher’s attempt at verbal correction, or the return of a marked paper, the enunciation of the verdict accomplishes an act of failing, instantaneously transforming the pending ‘knowledge’ into ‘trash.’ [29] When I reflect on epistemic trash, I think of a particular piece of my own writing: a draft chapter of my dissertation for the SOAS University of London’s Master of Research (MRes) in Politics with Language (Japanese). I titled my (final) dissertation: “The German Red Army Faction and the ‘War on Terror.’” In my MRes dissertation, I set out to illuminate the reconfiguration of the discourse of the Red Army Faction (RAF, a left-wing terrorist group in postwar West-Germany) in the post-9/11 ‘war on terror.’ I worked with the tentative thesis that in the ‘war on terror,’ the othering of non-Western Islamist terrorists facilitated a transformation of the RAF from a condemnable renegade into a preferable enemy because the RAF’s familiarity now constituted it as an intelligible opponent. Until 2017, the intercollegiate SOAS Politics MRes program with Birkbeck University of London was a two-year program that accepted students from different disciplinary backgrounds and offered students training in social science methods. Teaching staff at SOAS often emphasized the unique preparation this degree offered for a subsequent academic career, reflected in part in the 25,000-word dissertations that MRes students produced (compared to a more typical 10,000-word limit). In this essay, however, I refer to the recent SOAS guidelines and assessment criteria for such 10,000-word dissertations in one-year Politics Master’s programs. These guidelines more closely resemble the requirements of other higher education institutions across the United Kingdom (UK). [30] In my experience, however, SOAS is uniquely open towards heterodox methods, as well as methodological and theoretical approaches and the study of ‘niche’ empirical phenomena. After completing my MRes, I continued under the same supervisors at SOAS to…